Money 101

GIS Explained: Why a TFSA Withdrawal Is Free and an RRSP One Is Not

A TFSA withdrawal leaves the Guaranteed Income Supplement untouched, while each RRSP dollar can cut it by 50 cents or more. Here is the rule and a worked example.

RetireSmarter · November 3, 2026

If you receive the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS), or expect to, where your savings sit matters as much as how much you have. Money you take out of a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) does not count as income for the GIS, so your supplement stays the same. Money you take out of a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) or a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) does count, and the Old Age Security Act reduces the supplement by one dollar for each full two dollars of income.

That is where the “50 cents on the dollar” comes from. For a single person at the lowest incomes, the loss can reach 75 cents, because a second part of the supplement shrinks at the same time. And that is before any income tax on the withdrawal.

Who gets the GIS and how much

The GIS is a monthly, tax-free payment for people 65 or older who receive the Old Age Security (OAS) pension, live in Canada and have income under a set limit. For October to December 2026, Service Canada lists a maximum of $1,138.90 a month for a single, widowed or divorced person with annual income under $23,112. For a couple where both receive the full OAS pension, the maximum is $685.56 a month each, with combined income under $30,528.

Our Guaranteed Income Supplement guide shows the full set of amounts and limits for every situation, refreshed each morning from Service Canada. The amounts rise each January, April, July and October with the cost of living, and they never go down.

What counts as income for the GIS

The Old Age Security Act starts from your income as calculated for income tax, then takes a few things out. The main ones:

  • The OAS pension and the GIS themselves do not count.
  • The first $5,000 of employment and self-employment income does not count, and neither does half of the next $10,000. This exemption has applied to benefits for months after June 2020.
  • CPP and QPP pensions, workplace pensions, interest, dividends, capital gains and rental income all count.
  • RRSP and RRIF withdrawals count in full. The earnings exemption covers work income only, so it does not shelter them.

A TFSA sits outside all of this. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) states plainly that income earned in a TFSA, and withdrawals from it, do not affect federal income-tested benefits, and it names the OAS pension and the GIS. A TFSA withdrawal is not taxable, so it never appears in the income Service Canada uses.

The 50 cent rule, in the Act’s own words

Section 12 of the Old Age Security Act sets the supplement at the maximum amount “minus one dollar for each full two dollars of the pensioner’s monthly base income.” For a single person, monthly base income is one twelfth of last year’s income. So every $1,000 of countable income in a year takes $500 off the following year’s supplement, spread over 12 cheques.

There is a second piece. Section 12.1 adds a top-up to the supplement, first paid in 2011 and increased in July 2016. For a single person, the top-up is reduced by one dollar for every four dollars of monthly income above $2,000 a year. While both pieces are shrinking, each extra dollar of income costs 75 cents of GIS. Once the top-up is fully used up, the rate drops back to 50 cents. Service Canada does not show the top-up as a separate dollar amount on its payment pages, so the income level where it runs out is not listed there; Service Canada’s Old Age Security Benefits Estimator, linked from its GIS pages, will run your own numbers.

A $5,000 withdrawal, side by side

Take a single person, 67, receiving the full OAS pension and some GIS. They need $5,000 for a new roof and can take it from a TFSA or an RRSP. The table shows what changes. The GIS figures are RetireSmarter’s calculation from the formulas in sections 12 and 12.1 of the Old Age Security Act, before small rounding.

$5,000 from a TFSA$5,000 from an RRSP
Tax withheld by the financial institutionNone$500 (10% on amounts up to $5,000, outside Quebec)
Counts as income for the GISNoYes, all $5,000
GIS change for the following July to JuneNone$2,500 less for the year, or up to $3,750 less if the top-up is still being paid
Income tax on the withdrawalNoneAdded to taxable income for the year

The withholding is not the final bill. The CRA notes that the tax withheld may not cover what you owe at your bracket, and you settle the difference on your return. Whatever the tax turns out to be, the GIS loss arrives as well, a year later, when Service Canada recalculates the supplement each July using the previous calendar year’s income.

Withdrawal size matters for withholding too. The CRA rate is 20% on an RRSP withdrawal over $5,000 up to $15,000, and 30% above $15,000 (5%, 10% and 15% federal in Quebec, plus Quebec tax). Our income tax calculator estimates the tax side for your province.

Couples share the reduction

For a couple who both receive OAS, the Act uses one twenty-fourth of combined income as each spouse’s monthly base income. In practice, a $5,000 RRSP withdrawal by either spouse takes $1,250 a year off each partner’s supplement, $2,500 together, plus up to another $625 each while the top-up portion is still being paid. That is RetireSmarter’s calculation from the same sections of the Act.

So the household loses the same 50 cents a dollar, it just comes out of two cheques. It also means that, for the GIS, it makes no difference which spouse makes the withdrawal; combined income is what counts. Our couples retirement planner lets you test both incomes together.

Why timing matters as much as the account

Because each GIS year runs from July to June on the previous calendar year’s income, the calendar year of a withdrawal decides which GIS year it touches. A large RRSP withdrawal taken in a year whose income never feeds into a GIS calculation does not reduce the supplement at all. That is the idea behind drawing an RRSP down earlier, which our RRSP meltdown guide covers in detail, including the trade-offs with income tax and the OAS clawback.

RRIF minimum withdrawals work against this. Once an RRSP becomes a RRIF, a minimum amount must come out each year, and every dollar of it counts as GIS income. The RRIF minimum withdrawal calculator shows the required amount by age.

If your income has dropped because you retired, or a pension was reduced or stopped, Service Canada can set your GIS using an estimate of this year’s income instead of last year’s. You ask for that by contacting them.

What this means for where you save

None of this makes an RRSP wrong. The deduction can be worth a lot during working years, and many people with a workplace pension or larger savings will never qualify for the GIS. The point is narrower: for people whose retirement income is likely to fall under the GIS limits, an RRSP dollar can come out worth far less than it looked going in, while a TFSA dollar comes out whole.

Our RRSP vs TFSA guide walks through who tends to benefit from each, and the RRSP vs TFSA calculator compares the two for your own tax rates. For this quarter’s full benefit table, see our post on OAS, GIS and Allowance amounts for October to December 2026. The next GIS payment lands on November 26, 2026; every date is on our OAS payment dates page.

What to do next

Sources

General information, not financial, tax or real-estate advice. Dollar figures are sourced and dated where shown, but prices and rules change — confirm the current numbers before acting, and consider professional advice for your situation. See our methodology.